Many authors dream of seeing their books transformed into Broadway sensations or blockbuster films—but the journey from novel to script isn’t always smooth, or even successful. Even with industry interest, the adaptation process can be full of creative compromises, unexpected detours, and reinventions that risk losing the heart of the original story. That’s what makes Wicked such a fascinating case. Originally a novel, then a record-breaking musical, and now a critically acclaimed film, Wicked has thrived across a variety of adaptations.

In today’s blog, Ginger digs into Wicked’s wildly successful evolution to uncover what it got so right, and what authors can learn from its journey. From story structure and thematic depth to the art of staying flexible while preserving your story’s core, Wicked offers authors a blueprint for crafting work that can leap off the page and come alive on stage or screen. 

---

I recently watched the Wicked movie and hadn’t expected to love it nearly as much as I did. Being a typical red-blooded man, I prefer my movies to have guns and explosions. Instead, I found myself swept away by a tale of magic and friendship in a far-off land. I even had to wipe tears from my eyes at some points!

And I’m not alone! Wicked has seemingly taken the world by storm. The wildest part, in fact, is how so many influencers and online pundits went into the movie concerned that it would be “woke” or inauthentic, yet emerged as fans. After watching a lengthy video of right-wing commentator Ben Shapiro praising the film, I realized the movie must be something truly special to appeal to such a diverse (and divisive) fanbase.

But just what makes it so special? And what can we, as aspiring authors, learn from it?

After all, haven’t you ever fantasized about your book dazzling audiences on Broadway or captivating viewers on the silver screen? For many authors, seeing their story leap from page to stage (or cinema) would be a dream come true (including me! But you might have to wait a while before Sold to the Cartel or Beauty and the Biker Boss makes it to Broadway.)

But what makes an adaptation truly succeed? The journey of Wicked—from Gregory Maguire’s 1995 novel to a record-breaking musical and now a blockbuster movie—offers a blueprint for turning that dream into reality. By examining where Wicked got it right, maybe you can uncover the secrets to crafting a story that thrives beyond the written word. Let’s dive into its transformation and see what aspiring authors can take away.

The Book: A Fresh Take That Begged for Adaptation

It all starts with Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West. Published in 1995, Gregory Maguire’s novel flips L. Frank Baum’s The Wonderful Wizard of Oz on its head, giving the Wicked Witch—named Elphaba—a compelling, humanized backstory. With its dark exploration of prejudice, power, and identity, the book carved out a niche among readers craving a fresh spin on a classic tale.

Where Wicked got it right: Maguire’s bold reimagination made the story adaptable from the start. By taking a familiar narrative and infusing it with complex characters and provocative themes, he handed adapters a goldmine of material to explore. For authors, this is a lesson in writing with adaptation potential—a unique twist on something recognizable can catch the eye of producers and directors looking for the “next big thing!”

The Journey from Page to Screen: Strategic Brilliance

Wicked didn’t leap to the spotlight overnight—it took a calculated path. The book’s growing cult following inspired a Broadway musical in 2003, produced by Universal Pictures’ stage division. Composer Stephen Schwartz and writer Winnie Holzman distilled the novel’s sprawling narrative into a tight, emotional powerhouse, complete with show stopping songs like “Defying Gravity.” The result? A Tony-winning juggernaut that’s still running after two decades (I’ve seen it twice myself, in London and New York.)

Fast forward to 2024, and director Jon M. Chu brought Wicked to the big screen in Wicked: Part I, starring Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande. Splitting the story into two films, Chu preserved its depth while adding cinematic grandeur—building on the musical’s success.

But my favorite part? Despite adapting an adaptation, Chu was sure to weave in nods to the original novel; which is the sort of thing that warms my author’s heart.

Where Wicked got it right: The adapters made smart, medium-specific choices. The musical simplified complex subplots to hook a broader audience, while the movie amplified the spectacle with visuals and expanded storytelling. This adaptability kept the story’s soul alive across formats. For authors, the takeaway is to craft a narrative flexible enough to evolve—whether it’s streamlined for the stage or enriched for film—without losing what makes it special.

And don’t take my word for it! Look at other stories that have thrived across multiple adaptations. My favorite is The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams—a radio play which was adapted into a hit book series, a popular television series, and eventually a successful movie (although not successful enough to earn a sequel.)

Each adaptation made changes to better suit how it was being told; making every version fresh and exciting even to those of us who’d eagerly consumed every adaptation that had come before.

Smart Changes That Elevated the Story

Adaptation isn’t about copying—it’s about enhancing. Wicked’s transformations prove this.

• Book to Musical: The musical dialed back the novel’s gritty politics, spotlighting Elphaba’s friendship with Glinda and added a love triangle with Fiyero for extra drama. These tweaks turned a dense tale into a crowd-pleasing hit, proving that accessibility matters on stage.
• Musical to Movie: The film stays true to the musical but digs deeper—fleshing out Elphaba’s early years and her bond with her sister Nessarose. Subtle Wizard of Oz Easter eggs, like Dorothy’s cameos, add cinematic magic without straying from the core.

Where Wicked got it right: Each shift played to the medium’s strengths—spectacle and song for Broadway, visuals and depth for film. For authors, this means writing characters and themes that can flex across formats, shining whether they’re sung or shown in IMAX.

Staying True to the Core: The Glue That Held It Together

Through every change, certain elements of Wicked remained rock-solid:

• Themes of Justice: The mistreatment of Oz’s talking animals and the Wizard’s tyranny remain, grounding the story in its social critique (and one that’s very relevant to the politics of the current moment!)
• Elphaba’s Depth: She’s never just a villain—she’s a misunderstood soul shaped by her world, a trait that carries through every version.
• The Elphaba-Glinda Bond: Their evolving relationship is the heartbeat of Wicked, driving its emotional pull no matter the medium.

Where Wicked got it right: These anchors kept the story recognizable and resonant. For authors, it’s a reminder to pinpoint your story’s non-negotiables—the pieces that must endure to keep its identity intact through any adaptation.

Reception: Proof It Worked

Wicked: Part I hit theaters in 2024 to glowing reviews. Critics lauded its loyalty to the musical, Erivo and Grande’s electric performances, and its stunning visuals. Fans adored how it blended nostalgia with fresh surprises, cementing Wicked’s status as an adaptation triumph. Its success ties back to honoring Maguire’s novel and the musical’s legacy while embracing film’s unique possibilities.

Where Wicked got it right: It struck a balance between reverence and innovation, delivering a story that feels timeless yet tailored to today. Authors take note: a story with universal appeal and room to grow can win hearts across generations and formats.

Wicked Lessons for Aspiring Authors

Dreaming of your book on stage or screen? Here’s what Wicked teaches us:

1. Build an Adaptable Foundation: A strong premise or characters with depth can stretch across mediums—think big, but leave room for reinterpretation.
2. Know Your Audience: Stage fans want spectacle; moviegoers crave immersion. Write with flexibility to meet those needs.
3. Collaborate Openly: Wicked thrived thanks to teamwork. Be ready to partner with adapters to refine your vision.
4. Guard the Heart: Know your story’s essence—its themes or emotional stakes—and protect them through every change.
5. Think Cinematically: Vivid scenes and strong emotions translate anywhere. Give adapters a canvas to paint on.

Final Curtain

Wicked’s evolution from a quirky novel to a Broadway icon and a cinematic event shows how a story can soar when it’s adaptable yet true to itself. For authors with adaptation dreams, it’s a shining example: with the right mix of creativity, flexibility, and core strength, your book could light up a stage or screen too. 

Is that your dream? Would you love to see your story as a musical or movie? What from Wicked’s journey sparks your imagination? Drop your thoughts below—I’d love to read them!

Share this blog